Engagement ring after wedding
Question:
Susan, A good jeweler should be able to modify the setting on your engagement ring so that it can be worn with a non-notched band. I recently had my engagement ring modified to go with a band. It’s a single diamond set in a platinum band. The diamond is encircled by a bezel (sp???) and the level of the top surface of the diamond is flush with the ring band. I love it this way, but having the diamond set flush made it look not quite right with a band because not only were the two rings unable to lie flat against each other (a thin like of skin might actually look nice) but the engagement ring tended to tilt away from the wedding band and look awkward. So the jeweler took a small notch out of the bezel itself, which is virtually invisible from above. During the remainder of my engagment, I’m wearing the engagement ring alone, and the notch is not noticable. When I get married, the wedding band will fit nicely under the notch, which will be invisible as long as I wear both rings. My point is that if you get a skilled, creative jeweler, they *can* make the two rings work together with some slight modifications. Good luck. Let us know how it goes. jb – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Susan, Have you tried the 2 of them together without the notch? They may be fine together. I’ve tried it with the plain band-style ring I occasionally wear, and it doesn’t work at all. The sapphire extends far enough below the bottom edge of its band that it rides up awkwardly when I wear it with another ring. I suppose I should’ve thought of that when we picked out the ring, but I didn’t. It was a beautiful ring, it was *well* within our price range (thanks to after-Christmas sales!), and having been proposed to the night before, I wanted a ring on my finger, so I could feel Finally Officially Engaged.
It’s still beautiful, and we’ll find a way to make it work, or at least to salvage the sapphire. –Susan (and Dylan) 9/4/99
Response:
Stacey, I am in the same situation. I also have small hands and wear very little jewelry. My engagement ring covers a lot of surface area and both my fiance and I agree that adding a band would make it too much. Even a very thin band would change the look of the ring. I plan to wear my engagement ring as my wedding band. We will also purchase a thin band that I can wear in situations I choose not to wear my engagement ring (ie. working in the yard). When we first bought the ring I had the same concerns about people thinking I was perpetually engaged. After having some time to think about it, I decided that it doesn’t really matter to me what other people think. When I got engaged I started noticing rings more and was very surprised at the number of people who only wear bands. Do people spend time worring about whether these women actually have engagement rings or not? The people who know you will know that you are married. The people who don’t know you and are concerned enough about your marital status will probably find out from someone else anyway. Becky – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – My situation is the opposite of the earlier poster- My fiance and I are considering using my engagement ring to double as my wedding band. I have small hands and do not wear a lot of jewelry. A band worn with my engagement ring would be too much! I already wear a very special ring on my right hand so I do not want to also wear my engagement ring on that hand. Will people assume that I am not married, just perpetually engaged? I realize that I can do pretty much whatever I want to, but is this rather against the norm? Stacey
Response:
I suppose I should’ve thought of that when we picked out the ring, but I didn’t. It was a beautiful ring, it was *well* within our price range (thanks to after-Christmas sales!), and having been proposed to the night before, I wanted a ring on my finger, so I could feel Finally Officially Engaged.
It’s still beautiful, and we’ll find a way to make it work, or at least to salvage the sapphire.
Susan: Have you considered having the sapphire and the setting removed and put on a necklace? Just a thought. Star (and Emmett May 16, 1999 (omigosh only 27 days and counting!))
Response:
I already wear a very special ring on my right hand so I do not want to also wear my engagement ring on that hand. Will people assume that I am not married, just perpetually engaged?
I agree with what Wende said. I don’t think it’s odd at all, but there are people who will ask (again and again and again) <g. Have you thought about buying a very thin gold band (like a 2mm) and having it soldered to (or wearing it with) your engagement band? A wedding ring doesn’t have to be big or chunky to be a wedding band. Karen — Karen Simmons, Photographer The DK Gallery http://www.thedkgallery.com
Response:
Greetings and Happy Sunday! However, I *really* don’t like gold and am mildy allergic to it. I now take it off at night and that stops me from having a reaction, but if I leave it on for a couple of days straight, my finger starts to itch. Pure gold will not give you a reaction. But even 24k is still only 48% gold, and there is no control over what the other 52% has to be.
24k is pure gold. You’re thinking of 14k, which is 48% gold/52% other. 24k is, generally speaking, far too soft to use for jewelry, particularly rings, which often take a lot of punishment. A good compromise is 18k, which is 75% gold/25% silver. I think it’s much richer looking than 14k. Most likely you are having a reaction to copper, pewter, tin, nickle, or anything else the shop had laying around when it came time to cast your grandmother’s ring.
You are exactly right. IME, nickel is usually the culprit in metal allergies, though others can cause problems too. <shameless plug Titanium is one of the most hypoallergenic metals available. Email me if you’d like info on our ring styles. </shameless plug Rachel, to Jeremy, September 15, 2001 Assoc Designer, Titanium Art Studios "A blisful lyf, a paisible and a swete, Ledden the peples in the former age." Chaucer, "The Former Age."
Response:
My situation is the opposite of the earlier poster- My fiance and I are considering using my engagement ring to double as my wedding band. I have small hands and do not wear a lot of jewelry. A band worn with my engagement ring would be too much! I already wear a very special ring on my right hand so I do not want to also wear my engagement ring on that hand. Will people assume that I am not married, just perpetually engaged? I realize that I can do pretty much whatever I want to, but is this rather against the norm?
It’s unusual, but as you’ve noticed, no one can really *stop* you from doing it.
The only situation where I could see this becoming an annoyance is if you work in a field where you’re constantly meeting with salespeople (or possibly interviewing job candidates). These are situations where people look for conversation starters, so they’ll tend to exclaim, "What a lovely engagement ring! When is the wedding?" How tolerant are you of hearing the same question over and over? If you ordinarily see the same few people, they’ll quickly get used to your ring-wearing habits and forget about it. True strangers’ opinions don’t count anyway. Wende
Response:
Susan, Have you tried the 2 of them together without the notch? They may be fine together.
I’ve tried it with the plain band-style ring I occasionally wear, and it doesn’t work at all. The sapphire extends far enough below the bottom edge of its band that it rides up awkwardly when I wear it with another ring. I suppose I should’ve thought of that when we picked out the ring, but I didn’t. It was a beautiful ring, it was *well* within our price range (thanks to after-Christmas sales!), and having been proposed to the night before, I wanted a ring on my finger, so I could feel Finally Officially Engaged.
It’s still beautiful, and we’ll find a way to make it work, or at least to salvage the sapphire. –Susan (and Dylan) 9/4/99
Response:
My situation is the opposite of the earlier poster- My fiance and I are considering using my engagement ring to double as my wedding band. I have small hands and do not wear a lot of jewelry. A band worn with my engagement ring would be too much! I already wear a very special ring on my right hand so I do not want to also wear my engagement ring on that hand. Will people assume that I am not married, just perpetually engaged? I realize that I can do pretty much whatever I want to, but is this rather against the norm? Stacey – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – So, what do I do? Can I just not wear my engagement ring after I get married? My FH thinks that’s horrible and that people won’t think that I’m married. However, my mother does not wear an engagement ring with her band and my grandmother did not even wear this ring except for special occasions. What should I do? Is this really as blasphemous as my FH says? An engagement ring has nothing to do with being married. Actually an engagement ring has nothing to do with being engaged either, except as a symbol. You can be engaged and/or married without any kind of jewelry whatsoever. I know many women who don’t wear or didn’t even have engagement rings and no one thinks they aren’t married because they wear a wedding ring only. I could see your FH’s point (maybe) if you didn’t want to wear a wedding ring, but to say people won’t think you’re married if you’re wearing a wedding ring and not an engagement ring is just plain silly. It seems to me like there might be another issue here for your FH that he isn’t bringing up. FWIW, I don’t wear my engagement ring except for special occasions. I found when I was working that I would get the ring caught on the lining of my camera bag frequently. Because of that, I opted for a plain gold band as my wedding ring, and I now wear my engagement ring on my right hand only when we go out. Hope this helps some, Karen — Karen Simmons, Photographer The DK Gallery http://www.thedkgallery.com
Response:
Susan, Have you tried the 2 of them together without the notch? They may be fine together. The reason I say so is that my wedding band does not rest smoothly right up against my engagement ring either and I did not want/couldn’t have a notch taken in the wedding band (it’s like an anniversary band). Even though there is a small space between both rings, it really looks good and I wouldn’t have it any other way. HTH, Kirsten – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I haven’t decided what to do about my engagement ring once I’m married. It’s an oval sapphire with a small diamond on either side, and the sapphire is large enough that I’d have to have a notch cut in the wedding band for the two rings to fit smoothly together. That would look fine with a plain wedding band, but Dylan and I like the idea of Celtic rings, and I’d hate to chop a notch out of a knotwork pattern. I’m considering having the sapphire reset as part of the wedding band. I don’t want to switch it to my right hand, because then I couldn’t wear the claddagh ring Dylan bought me before we were engaged. –Susan (and Dylan) 9/4/99
Response:
Many women don’t wear an engagement ring. It’s the wedding band that signifies you’re married, that’s why you get it during the *wedding* ceremony. Tell your FH to lighten up! Lis – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Greetings and Happy Sunday! I really need help with this. As an engagement ring, I am wearing my late grandmother’s diamond wedding ring. It is lovely, but it is gold, which I really don’t like. We wanted to save money on a ring and so that’s why we’re using it. (Note: I was *very* close to my grandmother so it is quite an honor for me, also.) However, I *really* don’t like gold and am mildy allergic to it. I now take it off at night and that stops me from having a reaction, but if I leave it on for a couple of days straight, my finger starts to itch. I cannot wear gold earring for the same reason. I recently found the wedding ring of my dreams! It kind of shaped like and infinity symbol with lots of diamonds – but there’s a problem with it. It’s platinum, which I love. Also, the shape of it really prohibits wearing an engagement ring with it like any kind of a wrap or whatever. So, what do I do? Can I just not wear my engagement ring after I get married? My FH thinks that’s horrible and that people won’t think that I’m married. However, my mother does not wear an engagement ring with her band and my grandmother did not even wear this ring except for special occasions. What should I do? Is this really as blasphemous as my FH says? Thanks! Sarah To Jim, 7/1/00
Response:
Greetings and Happy Sunday! I really need help with this. As an engagement ring, I am wearing my late grandmother’s diamond wedding ring. It is lovely, but it is gold, which I really don’t like. We wanted to save money on a ring and so that’s why we’re using it. (Note: I was *very* close to my grandmother so it is quite an honor for me, also.) However, I *really* don’t like gold and am mildy allergic to it. I now take it off at night and that stops me from having a reaction, but if I leave it on for a couple of days straight, my finger starts to itch.
Definitely don’t wear anything you’re allergic to! No need to suffer for it. I like the idea of having the stones reset, perhaps in a very similar design to your grandmother’s ring. I have one friend who’s allergic to most jewelry who wears her wedding band and engagement ring as a necklace on a long chain. That way, they rest against the fabric of her shirt instead of her skin, and she avoids the hives. I’ve never seen my mother wear her engagement ring. I think at one point her rings didn’t fit her anymore, and she got a new wedding band but not engagement ring. She just keeps it in her jewelry box. Maybe she had some thoughts of passing it on to a daughter or daughter-in-law, but it just hasn’t worked out that way. I haven’t decided what to do about my engagement ring once I’m married. It’s an oval sapphire with a small diamond on either side, and the sapphire is large enough that I’d have to have a notch cut in the wedding band for the two rings to fit smoothly together. That would look fine with a plain wedding band, but Dylan and I like the idea of Celtic rings, and I’d hate to chop a notch out of a knotwork pattern. I’m considering having the sapphire reset as part of the wedding band. I don’t want to switch it to my right hand, because then I couldn’t wear the claddagh ring Dylan bought me before we were engaged. –Susan (and Dylan) 9/4/99
Response:
Can I just not wear my engagement ring after I get married? My FH thinks that’s horrible and that people won’t think that I’m married.
Um, your wedding ring is the sign that you’re married. I suppose it’s possible that people will think you’re not engaged… but once you’re married, you’re *not* engaged any more, so what’s the difference? Since getting married, I always wear my engagement ring on my right hand, and it doesn’t look like a conventional engagement ring anyway. No one has ever commented. My mother never wore her engagement ring that I can remember. I know one person who seems to wear different rings every day — I have no idea if *any* of them are her official wedding and engagement rings, although she’s definitely married. Wende
Response:
I recently found the wedding ring of my dreams! It kind of shaped like and infinity symbol with lots of diamonds – but there’s a problem with it. It’s platinum, which I love. Also, the shape of it really prohibits wearing an engagement ring with it like any kind of a wrap or whatever. So, what do I do? Can I just not wear my engagement ring after I get married?
Hi Sarah, No, you don’t have to wear your engagement ring after you get married. One of my friends never even got an engagement ring when she got engaged. She and her husband have been married for over 5 years now, and all this time, she’s worn only her wedding band. Nenette
Response:
Why don’t you have the diamond reset?
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Greetings and Happy Sunday! I really need help with this. As an engagement ring, I am wearing my late grandmother’s diamond wedding ring. It is lovely, but it is gold, which I really don’t like. We wanted to save money on a ring and so that’s why we’re using it. (Note: I was *very* close to my grandmother so it is quite an honor for me, also.) However, I *really* don’t like gold and am mildy allergic to it. I now take it off at night and that stops me from having a reaction, but if I leave it on for a couple of days straight, my finger starts to itch. I cannot wear gold earring for the same reason. I recently found the wedding ring of my dreams! It kind of shaped like and infinity symbol with lots of diamonds – but there’s a problem with it. It’s platinum, which I love. Also, the shape of it really prohibits wearing an engagement ring with it like any kind of a wrap or whatever. So, what do I do? Can I just not wear my engagement ring after I get married? My FH thinks that’s horrible and that people won’t think that I’m married. However, my mother does not wear an engagement ring with her band and my grandmother did not even wear this ring except for special occasions. What should I do? Is this really as blasphemous as my FH says? Thanks! Sarah To Jim, 7/1/00
Response:
So, what do I do? Can I just not wear my engagement ring after I get married? My FH thinks that’s horrible and that people won’t think that I’m married. However, my mother does not wear an engagement ring with her band and my grandmother did not even wear this ring except for special occasions. What should I do? Is this really as blasphemous as my FH says?
An engagement ring has nothing to do with being married. Actually an engagement ring has nothing to do with being engaged either, except as a symbol. You can be engaged and/or married without any kind of jewelry whatsoever. I know many women who don’t wear or didn’t even have engagement rings and no one thinks they aren’t married because they wear a wedding ring only. I could see your FH’s point (maybe) if you didn’t want to wear a wedding ring, but to say people won’t think you’re married if you’re wearing a wedding ring and not an engagement ring is just plain silly. It seems to me like there might be another issue here for your FH that he isn’t bringing up. FWIW, I don’t wear my engagement ring except for special occasions. I found when I was working that I would get the ring caught on the lining of my camera bag frequently. Because of that, I opted for a plain gold band as my wedding ring, and I now wear my engagement ring on my right hand only when we go out. Hope this helps some, Karen — Karen Simmons, Photographer The DK Gallery http://www.thedkgallery.com
Response:
Greetings and Happy Sunday! However, I *really* don’t like gold and am mildy allergic to it. I now take it off at night and that stops me from having a reaction, but if I leave it on for a couple of days straight, my finger starts to itch.
Pure gold will not give you a reaction. But even 24k is still only 48% gold, and there is no control over what the other 52% has to be. Most likely you are having a reaction to copper, pewter, tin, nickle, or anything else the shop had laying around when it came time to cast your grandmother’s ring. Can I just not wear my engagement ring after I get married? My FH thinks that’s horrible and that people won’t think that I’m married. However, my mother does not wear an engagement ring with her band and my grandmother did not even wear this ring except for special occasions. What should I do? Is this really as blasphemous as my FH says?
A wedding ring is a sign that you are married, not the engagement ring. As for what people think, those who need to know if you are married ( and very few really *need* to know this) will outright ask you when the time comes. It’s really nobody else’s business what your marital status is. If you want people to know you will wear your wedding ring and make comments like "My husband and I had a great time this weekend…" You already treasure your grandmother’s ring. Keep it, but if it gives you a rash, keep it in a box. Dawn — Batgirl was a Librarian, too! http://www.he.net/~dduperal/ anti-spam reply: dduperault (at) aol.com
Response:
You can either somehow use the diamond from your grandmother’s with your ring, or you can just wear it on your right hand. You could have it reset too! Kelli – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Greetings and Happy Sunday! I really need help with this. As an engagement ring, I am wearing my late grandmother’s diamond wedding ring. It is lovely, but it is gold, which I really don’t like. We wanted to save money on a ring and so that’s why we’re using it. (Note: I was *very* close to my grandmother so it is quite an honor for me, also.) However, I *really* don’t like gold and am mildy allergic to it. I now take it off at night and that stops me from having a reaction, but if I leave it on for a couple of days straight, my finger starts to itch. I cannot wear gold earring for the same reason. I recently found the wedding ring of my dreams! It kind of shaped like and infinity symbol with lots of diamonds – but there’s a problem with it. It’s platinum, which I love. Also, the shape of it really prohibits wearing an engagement ring with it like any kind of a wrap or whatever. So, what do I do? Can I just not wear my engagement ring after I get married? My FH thinks that’s horrible and that people won’t think that I’m married. However, my mother does not wear an engagement ring with her band and my grandmother did not even wear this ring except for special occasions. What should I do? Is this really as blasphemous as my FH says? Thanks! Sarah To Jim, 7/1/00
Response:
says… I recently found the wedding ring of my dreams! It kind of shaped like and infinity symbol with lots of diamonds – but there’s a problem with it. It’s platinum, which I love. Also, the shape of it really prohibits wearing an engagement ring with it like any kind of a wrap or whatever. So, what do I do? Can I just not wear my engagement ring after I get married?
Absolutely. Many women don’t have engagement rings at all! My engagement ring doesn’t "match up" with my wedding band–were I to try to wear them on the same finger it would leave gaps, which I don’t like. For a while I wore my engagement ring on my right hand (you might have to have it resized for that) but now I just don’t wear it, because it gets caught on things (my hair!) and I’m paranoid about losing it =) Since you’re having an allergic reaction to yours, that sounds like an *excellent* reason to stop wearing it on a daily basis. Consider wearing it on your right hand, just for special occasions. My FH thinks that’s horrible and that people won’t think that I’m married.
Point out to FH that the engagement ring indicates you’re *engaged*, and the wedding ring indicates that you’re *married*. It also doesn’t matter if people think you’re married or not, and if your FH is really hung up on people knowing you’re "taken", I’d be worried. However, my mother does not wear an engagement ring with her band and my grandmother did not even wear this ring except for special occasions. What should I do? Is this really as blasphemous as my FH says?
Neither my mother, nor my MIL wear engagement rings (I don’t know if they have them) and they seem very married to me. I think you’re in the clear =) — This email address is unread due to spam. Please post all replies.
Response:
Hi, Sarah! We had a situation very similar to this. When Jason proposed we really did not want to spend a lot of money on an engagement ring. FMIL had a ring that was a diamond band in silver that she had intended to give to Jason someday, so that is what he gave me. It was beautiful and I loved it. I am allergic to silver, though. I had to take the ring off everynight and I still broke out in hives. It got so bad at one point that not only did my finger break out but my palm and other fingers did also. I switched the ring to my other hand only to have the same thing happen. I eventually had to just stop wearning it and it broke my heart. So we just went out and got me a new diamond ring. A more traditional one… half a carat solitiare in white gold because I’m not allergic to it and (to me) it looks just like silver. So we are now going to use the diamond band of FMIL as a wedding band and we are going to have the whole thing reset in white gold. That way it looks exactly the same, only it won’t make me break out. Maybe you could have your grandmother’s ring reset in the exact same style as it is now only in platinum so that you won’t break out and it will match the ring that you love so much? I don’t think it is so bad if you don’t wear your engagement ring… almost all of the women I work with wear only their bands. They have fancy diamond bands (most are the type that another ring cannot be worn with) and only wear their engagement rings on special occasions. Maybe you could wear your grandmothers ring on another finger or on the other hand after the wedding? Stefani marrying Jason 10/2/99 ( www.Geocities.com/Wellesley/Gazebo/8358 )
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Greetings and Happy Sunday! I really need help with this. As an engagement ring, I am wearing my late grandmother’s diamond wedding ring. It is lovely, but it is gold, which I really don’t like. We wanted to save money on a ring and so that’s why we’re using it. (Note: I was *very* close to my grandmother so it is quite an honor for me, also.) However, I *really* don’t like gold and am mildy allergic to it. I now take it off at night and that stops me from having a reaction, but if I leave it on for a couple of days straight, my finger starts to itch. I cannot wear gold earring for the same reason. I recently found the wedding ring of my dreams! It kind of shaped like and infinity symbol with lots of diamonds – but there’s a problem with it. It’s platinum, which I love. Also, the shape of it really prohibits wearing an engagement ring with it like any kind of a wrap or whatever. So, what do I do? Can I just not wear my engagement ring after I get married? My FH thinks that’s horrible and that people won’t think that I’m married. However, my mother does not wear an engagement ring with her band and my grandmother did not even wear this ring except for special occasions. What should I do? Is this really as blasphemous as my FH says? Thanks! Sarah To Jim, 7/1/00
Response:
Greetings and Happy Sunday! I really need help with this. As an engagement ring, I am wearing my late grandmother’s diamond wedding ring. It is lovely, but it is gold, which I really don’t like. We wanted to save money on a ring and so that’s why we’re using it. (Note: I was *very* close to my grandmother so it is quite an honor for me, also.) However, I *really* don’t like gold and am mildy allergic to it. I now take it off at night and that stops me from having a reaction, but if I leave it on for a couple of days straight, my finger starts to itch. I cannot wear gold earring for the same reason. I recently found the wedding ring of my dreams! It kind of shaped like and infinity symbol with lots of diamonds – but there’s a problem with it. It’s platinum, which I love. Also, the shape of it really prohibits wearing an engagement ring with it like any kind of a wrap or whatever. So, what do I do? Can I just not wear my engagement ring after I get married? My FH thinks that’s horrible and that people won’t think that I’m married. However, my mother does not wear an engagement ring with her band and my grandmother did not even wear this ring except for special occasions. What should I do? Is this really as blasphemous as my FH says? Thanks! Sarah To Jim, 7/1/00
Categories: