Question:
Thanks for all the good tips. I appreciate the feedback. Any more ideas are certainly welcome! Standard Disclaimer #143: I am not a doctor, blah blah blah… I am not giving medical advice, I am only giving testimony based on my experiences. Each person is responsible for what they do with information gathered. * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!
Well, I comparison shopped for a month or so before buying wedding rings, and ours were 3mm 14K gold for $40 each (yes, he happens to wear the same ring size as I do, so his ring and mine are identical). Granted, this was at JCPenney’s, but Michael’s (a "real" jewelry-only store) had the same ring and price (they didn’t happen to have any in stock the day we finally wanted to take them home, or we would have bought there). I gather that this is fairly cheap, so I wanted to mention that you don’t *have* to pay $100/up if you don’t want to, at least for simple gold bands. Tasha (the second, apparently!)
Response:
1) I’d like to know, what is the AVERAGE a guy is supposed to spend on an engagement ring and on wedding bands? I’ve heard the "2 months’ salary" rule, but I’m sure that was created by the DeBeers diamond industry! You’ve GOT to be kidding… Unless you make so much money that 2 months’ salary is NO problem, you’d have to be nuts to spend that much on a ring! Just my opinion… So, what is the average that a guy who only makes $45k/year (not much, living in L.A.!) should spend on a wedding ring? My fiancee’ would prefer a diamond solitaire type ring. I want to get something that looks good to the naked eye, and won’t break, but it doesn’t have to be real big or "perfect" under a microscope!
First of all, there is no set amount you should spend on a ring. I woudl suggest buying a ring you can afford fairly easily. I would recommend being able to pay cash for it (not pay it out for a year after she’s been wearing it). I would go for quality, not size. If your fiancee would like a solitaire, I would just start looking at solitaire rings. Does she prefer yellow gold or white gold? That is another consideration. Yellow gold is more classic, but white gold or platinum is the trend these days since many women wear silver a lot. There are 4 factors to look at when looking for a diamond — clarity, color, cut, and carat. I think the most important and visible is color, but that is my opinion. You have to look at many diamonds (preferably loose) to decide what is most important. I would get her a smaller really good quality diamond before I would even look at larger diamonds. 2) How much will I need to spend on gold wedding bands? Again, I don’t want to buy "cheap" stuff – I want the rings to be nice. But on the other hand I don’t want to go hogwild…
Our bands were $80 a piece. This is something you can get later and shop around for together. Our are 4mm yellow gold comfort fit bands. You can get wedding bands pretty cheaply. It is the symbolism that really counts. Since I’m getting married in Mexico, (to a Mexican woman), would I save money buy buying a ring in Mexico, or would I sacrifice quality by doing so? What is best – buying from a small jewelry store or from a big "Jewelry Exchange" or "Jewelry Mart" type super-store? What quality/grade diamond will I be looking for? How do I know it’s a good one?
I would probably stay away from Mexico because you can’t trust them all the time. We like small local stores, but they will not have as many diamonds to look at. I would go with a regional store, maybe. That is where all our rings came from (Americus Diamond). They should have lots of diamonds to look at and choose from. They can explain more about the quality. You can be sure you are getting what you paid for if the diamond is GIA certified. If it is not, the jeweler can pretty much tell you whatever he wants. There are papers that come with GIA certified diamonds that have all the specs including a drawing with all the inclusions, etc… You should also receive an appraisal when you buy the diamond for insurenace purposes. I hope this helps and didn’t just confuse you more. Good Luck. The best advice I can give is shop around until you are absolutely sure, and it doesn’t matter how big it is — she will know you love her just as much. DON’T GO INTO DEBT OVER THIS RING — YOU DO STILL HAVE A WEDDING AND A LIFE TO PLAN TOGETHER!! Kelli
Response:
Hi, I’m new to this board and to the whole concept of marriage. I know NOTHING about buying engagement rings. Never planned to get married, but now that I’ve found the right woman I find myself researching wedding-related topics! 1) I’d like to know, what is the AVERAGE a guy is supposed to spend on an engagement ring and on wedding bands? I’ve heard the "2 months’ salary" rule, but I’m sure that was created by the DeBeers diamond industry! You’ve GOT to be kidding… Unless you make so much money that 2 months’ salary is NO problem, you’d have to be nuts to spend that much on a ring! Just my opinion… So, what is the average that a guy who only makes $45k/year (not much, living in L.A.!) should spend on a wedding ring? My fiancee’ would prefer a diamond solitaire type ring. I want to get something that looks good to the naked eye, and won’t break, but it doesn’t have to be real big or "perfect" under a microscope! 2) How much will I need to spend on gold wedding bands? Again, I don’t want to buy "cheap" stuff – I want the rings to be nice. But on the other hand I don’t want to go hogwild… Since I’m getting married in Mexico, (to a Mexican woman), would I save money buy buying a ring in Mexico, or would I sacrifice quality by doing so? What is best – buying from a small jewelry store or from a big "Jewelry Exchange" or "Jewelry Mart" type super-store? What quality/grade diamond will I be looking for? How do I know it’s a good one? Any advice will be appreciated. Thanks! Any advice/ideas would be appreciated. Standard Disclaimer #143: I am not a doctor, blah blah blah… I am not giving medical advice, I am only giving testimony based on my experiences. Each person is responsible for what they do with information gathered. * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!
Response:
Cubic Zirconia you should be able to find extremely cheaply…I bought 2 1ct each stones (which look great!) for some studs since I can’t afford the real thing right now and they were $5 each. . . If you’re in the NYC area and interested, let me know because there’s a great place on 47th St. (but it is not on the street). I work in the diamond district and we go there (not for our customers, but when we want something nice mounted w/o spending the money)… Mountings should cost you between $225 and 300 (depends on plat or gold or white gold), but not everyone will mount a CZ — find a good mounting house in your area. Also, anyone that has really expensive studs or even a diamond engagement ring… a lot of our customers who have huge stones (I’ve seen rings with 8ct stones in them — huge!!!) who are planning on taking a vacation sometimes get the same thing mounted with a CZ to take instead, just in case. Just something to think about.
Jessica www.jessicaweiser.com
Response:
I would probably stay away from Mexico because you can’t trust them all the time.
Erm, just don’t mention to his future wife and in-laws that you can’t trust those Mexicans! After all, I presume he’ll want to be trusting his Mexican wife and potentially her Mexican family. Please be careful when making statements such as this. Insulting a whole country of people by stating they are untrustworthy is just not nice! That said, I don’t know anything about diamond buying in Mexico. I’ve not heard of it being a great place to get bargains on diamonds (eg compared to some other countries). In general, presuming you’re not living there now, I’d buy closer to home, that way you can go back to the shop if needbe for alterations, or can go a few times before you make any final buying decisions. I’m of the mind to get her to help you pick it out, as she’ll be wearing it. C. * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!
Response:
my suggestion to you is to try a pawn shop…..they have genuine diamonds and gold bands…the price will probably be just right for you too. Check out estate auctions as well, you never know what you might find there. Good Luck and congratulations…I am also engaged and my husband-to-be is going into the navy. I am excited and our wedding is almost a year away….I already have butterflies..lol. Anyway best of luck to you both!!! Shell
Response:
My fiancee’ has requested that I pick out the ring and "surprise" her. We did look at some and she indicated she preferred a solitaire diamond. However, I am going to try to get her to go look at some more with me, and maybe change her mind, at least give me an idea of the cut she likes and the syle of band she likes… As to color, cut, clarity and all that, I am getting a book highly recommended on Amazon.com… Hovever, the main problem I have is price. I really cannot afford more than a grand or so, and I dont know if one can buy a decent diamond ring for that…
My ring cost under 500 NZD, which in terms of buying power in the two countries, is probably under $350 USD, and it’s the most beautiful ring I’ve ever seen. :-) It’s not a diamond ring, but I think it looks much nicer than anything I’ve seen in a museum and anything else I saw in a jewellery shop. Hopefully your fiancee shares my taste for simplicity. Slightly more seriously, what determines the price of the ring is not so much its aesthetic appearance as the rarity of the stone and the expense of crafting the ring. Larger stones are rarer, thus more expensive, and purer stones, without flaws, are rarer, and thus more expensive. If you’re going to get detailed goldwork that the jeweller has to do under a microscope it will also cost more, but whether the end result looks better than an elegant plain band is another matter. So, in summary, I suggest stating or at least strongly hinting, at your money constraints to your fiancee, and look for a ring that looks beautiful, instea of trying to get the biggest stone you can afford. You should be able to find something very pleasing without spending vast sums of money. T.J. — http://homepages.ihug.co.nz/~tajwileb/ The right half of the brain controls the left half of the body. This means that only left handed people are in their right mind.
Response:
May I make a suggestion? You said that money is an issue at the moment because of paying for the wedding. Rather than buying a diamond you are not happy with, why not choose a nice band, and have it set with a cubic zirconia. (Not one of the obviously-fake-enormous ones! You can buy zirconias that are high quality and smaller in size. There’s a website dedicated to selling them, but I don’t have the address right now. Will post it later if you like.) The cost would probably be under $300, and you can have the zirconia replaced with a diamond when the money is there… first or fifth anniversary, perhaps. I have no idea how your significant other would feel about this. Some women might feel cheated or disappointed. Just a suggestion. * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!
Response:
My fiancee’ has requested that I pick out the ring and "surprise" her. We did look at some and she indicated she preferred a solitaire diamond. However, I am going to try to get her to go look at some more with me, and maybe change her mind, at least give me an idea of the cut she likes and the syle of band she likes… As to color, cut, clarity and all that, I am getting a book highly recommended on Amazon.com… Hovever, the main problem I have is price. I really cannot afford more than a grand or so, and I dont know if one can buy a decent diamond ring for that… The bottom line is, I need to discuss it with her, as due to extenuating circumstances I am "supposed" to pay for most of the wedding and reception as well, and Ii can’t really afford it… So, something’s got to give… Standard Disclaimer #143: I am not a doctor, blah blah blah… I am not giving medical advice, I am only giving testimony based on my experiences. Each person is responsible for what they do with information gathered. * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!
Response:
I am a married woman with very practical ideas, have been married for 23 years to the same man. Please, let your wife pick out her own ring. Do some reading about gold & precious gemstones. It is ridiculous to get caught up in the diamond cartel’s hype. You should get something that you can afford, that she is happy with. Unless she wants a diamond, other gemstones are usually less expensive & equally beautiful, so that is something to consider. The reason I am all for the woman getting to choose her own ring is because *she* will be the one wearing it. I am not going to explain all about gold & stones here, it just would take too much time & the info is easily available elsewhere. I also recommend going into Deja.com (net archival service) & reading in the misc.consumers.frugal-living archives under engagement/ wedding rings. There is a whole lot of good info there, it will help answer your questions Good luck, may your marriage last forever, with or without diamond rings. Melodi in VA – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi, I’m new to this board and to the whole concept of marriage. I know NOTHING about buying engagement rings. Never planned to get married, but now that I’ve found the right woman I find myself researching wedding-related topics! 1) I’d like to know, what is the AVERAGE a guy is supposed to spend on an engagement ring and on wedding bands? I’ve heard the "2 months’ salary" rule, but I’m sure that was created by the DeBeers diamond industry! You’ve GOT to be kidding… Unless you make so much money that 2 months’ salary is NO problem, you’d have to be nuts to spend that much on a ring! Just my opinion… So, what is the average that a guy who only makes $45k/year (not much, living in L.A.!) should spend on a wedding ring? My fiancee’ would prefer a diamond solitaire type ring. I want to get something that looks good to the naked eye, and won’t break, but it doesn’t have to be real big or "perfect" under a microscope! 2) How much will I need to spend on gold wedding bands? Again, I don’t want to buy "cheap" stuff – I want the rings to be nice. But on the other hand I don’t want to go hogwild… Since I’m getting married in Mexico, (to a Mexican woman), would I save money buy buying a ring in Mexico, or would I sacrifice quality by doing so? What is best – buying from a small jewelry store or from a big "Jewelry Exchange" or "Jewelry Mart" type super-store? What quality/grade diamond will I be looking for? How do I know it’s a good one? Any advice will be appreciated. Thanks! Any advice/ideas would be appreciated. Standard Disclaimer #143: I am not a doctor, blah blah blah… I am not giving medical advice, I am only giving testimony based on my experiences. Each person is responsible for what they do with information gathered. * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!
Response:
Hey there… I work for a diamond wholesaler (we’ve been in business 100 years, and it’s a very well-respected company in the industry and one of the largest)… Anyway, I do sales and work with people (mostly the large retailers–Nordstrom, Neimans, etc.) all day with the same questions you have… If you have any other questions please email me… otherwise, here is my reply to your message — and if anyone else needs advice, help, PLEASE email me! Cause a lot of times retailers *do not* know what they are talking about… and only want to sell sell sell… fiancee’ would prefer a diamond solitaire type ring. I want to get something that looks good to the naked eye, and won’t break, but it doesn’t have to be real big or "perfect" under a microscope!
Alright — definitely find out what she likes and what is most important to her… There are four "C’s" that most people in the industry refer to — color, cut, clarity, and carat weight. Find out (if you can) what SHE likes. Some women will take a diamond that is lower in color (like K–which is not great!) with a huge carat weight… Diamonds are graded like this: Color – range from D-M (or lower) and D is the higest… (and most expensive)… Then there is Clarity: goes from Internally Flawless (no inclusions) all the way down to Imperfect 1, 2, etc. In my opinion (and based on the work I do), you should either go with high color (like an F/G and a lower clarity like SI1 or 2) or lower the color (to maybe H or I) and make the clarity higher (like VS1 or 2)… The cut has everything to do with how the stone will look… how it sparkles and looks… it is SO important to get a well-cut stone… Look around because some places/retailers don’t stones that are well-cut… If you go to a retailer, dont’ let them talk you in to getting something like a D/VVS1 (one of the best) because you will spend a fortune on something that has barely-visible differences with a stone that is a G/SI1!! Perhaps it will be a little whiter, but for the money, definitely go with a little lower clarity/color. My engagement ring is a 3-stone ring oOo, G/SI1 .90ct center and 2 .26 stones on the side. I love it and I think the cut makes all the different… of course my company is also known for their well-cut stones
If you can, try to find a diamond wholesaler in your area. Unfortunately my company is private, so we deal with private customers, but you have to be referred by someone (we’re in NYC) to get up to our company and work w/ someone… We also deal with many major retailers and sell to them… If you let me know the area you’re in, I can refer you to the better retailers in your area… But wholesalers (the good ones) are the way to go… 2) How much will I need to spend on gold wedding bands? Again, I don’t want to buy "cheap" stuff – I want the rings to be nice. But on the other hand I don’t want to go hogwild…
Again: go for the wholesalers!! Look around… gold bands should NOT be expensive right now because the price of gold is down (and platinum is up!)… but retailers will mark it up quite a bit… I wouldn’t recommend going to a Jewelry Exchange at all… or a Jewelry Mart… Again, if you need help, let me refer you to someone in your area… A lot of retailers don’t know what they’re talking about and will talk you up in price or not give you the info you need! Email me if you have further questions… Hope this helps! I’m actually a singer-songwriter who is getting married next May, and stumbled upon this newsgroup… and it looks like my day job is paying off!
All the best, Jessica www.jessicaweiser.com
Response:
Thanks for all the good tips. I appreciate the feedback. Any more ideas are certainly welcome! Standard Disclaimer #143: I am not a doctor, blah blah blah… I am not giving medical advice, I am only giving testimony based on my experiences. Each person is responsible for what they do with information gathered. * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!
Response:
First of all, throw out that crap about spending two months salary on a ring. That was set up by jewelers. As a book I read said, "I’m sure the farmers of America would love to suggest that you spend a week’s salary on a dozen eggs, but that doesn’t mean you should do it." I have a TON of tips for buying a ring, and I’m a guy who returned the first ring I bought because it was lousy. Fortunately, I got my money back. The second time was the charm…I went against my conventional wisdom and bought my ring at www.tradeshop.com Definitely the best decision I could have made. The ring I bought for $2500 was appraised at over $4000, and the guy that appraised said I got a really good deal with them. We’re definitely ordering our wedding bands from them as well. About the ring: If you can afford a huge rock, go for it. However, the cut, clarity and color also make a HUGE difference. My fiancee’s stone is .68, but I made sure the cut was ideal, the clarity outstanding and the color as close to white as possible. Everywhere my fiancee goes, she gets compliments about her ring. I can’t say this enough: Even though many people are obsessed about how many carats a stone is, what does it matter if the other facets of the ring are horrible? The appraiser of my first ring said to me, "Rings are like vehicles. Would you rather drive a Ferrari or a school bus? One is huge and yellow, the other is smaller but catches everyone’s eye." Please e-mail me for more tips–I can tell you the mistakes I made when looking for a ring, and the right things that I did.
Response:
Purchase and read "How to Buy a Diamond" by Fred Cuellar. It will answer any and all questions about buying a diamond…including your two below. I got my copy from Amazon.com for $11.96. It was the best money we spent. I think when I retire from work (or eventually change careers I am going to go into gemology because of this book and the whole ring buying experience). Melissa to Chris (7-2-00) P.S. I am in no way affiliated with this book, I just love it so much and always suggest it when this thread topic comes up. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi, I’m new to this board and to the whole concept of marriage. I know NOTHING about buying engagement rings. Never planned to get married, but now that I’ve found the right woman I find myself researching wedding-related topics! 1) I’d like to know, what is the AVERAGE a guy is supposed to spend on an engagement ring and on wedding bands? I’ve heard the "2 months’ salary" rule, but I’m sure that was created by the DeBeers diamond industry! You’ve GOT to be kidding… Unless you make so much money that 2 months’ salary is NO problem, you’d have to be nuts to spend that much on a ring! Just my opinion… So, what is the average that a guy who only makes $45k/year (not much, living in L.A.!) should spend on a wedding ring? My fiancee’ would prefer a diamond solitaire type ring. I want to get something that looks good to the naked eye, and won’t break, but it doesn’t have to be real big or "perfect" under a microscope! 2) How much will I need to spend on gold wedding bands? Again, I don’t want to buy "cheap" stuff – I want the rings to be nice. But on the other hand I don’t want to go hogwild… Since I’m getting married in Mexico, (to a Mexican woman), would I save money buy buying a ring in Mexico, or would I sacrifice quality by doing so? What is best – buying from a small jewelry store or from a big "Jewelry Exchange" or "Jewelry Mart" type super-store? What quality/grade diamond will I be looking for? How do I know it’s a good one? Any advice will be appreciated. Thanks! Any advice/ideas would be appreciated.
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi, I’m new to this board and to the whole concept of marriage. I know NOTHING about buying engagement rings. Never planned to get married, but now that I’ve found the right woman I find myself researching wedding-related topics! 1) I’d like to know, what is the AVERAGE a guy is supposed to spend on an engagement ring and on wedding bands? I’ve heard the "2 months’ salary" rule, but I’m sure that was created by the DeBeers diamond industry! You’ve GOT to be kidding… Unless you make so much money that 2 months’ salary is NO problem, you’d have to be nuts to spend that much on a ring! Just my opinion… So, what is the average that a guy who only makes $45k/year (not much, living in L.A.!) should spend on a wedding ring? My fiancee’ would prefer a diamond solitaire type ring. I want to get something that looks good to the naked eye, and won’t break, but it doesn’t have to be real big or "perfect" under a microscope! 2) How much will I need to spend on gold wedding bands? Again, I don’t want to buy "cheap" stuff – I want the rings to be nice. But on the other hand I don’t want to go hogwild… Since I’m getting married in Mexico, (to a Mexican woman), would I save money buy buying a ring in Mexico, or would I sacrifice quality by doing so? What is best – buying from a small jewelry store or from a big "Jewelry Exchange" or "Jewelry Mart" type super-store? What quality/grade diamond will I be looking for? How do I know it’s a good one?
I suggest you spend what you can afford, it’s the thought that counts, don’t go into debt for this. Well, I just went through this myself, and I too bought a nice ring .63carats,total of .80, it’s a nice size stone, and 14k gold setting, I also didn’t buy the best, it’s an SI-1, excellent cut to reflect the light. $5000 canadian we just bought are wedding bands and spent a little more for hers as it is actually an anniversary band with diamonds, and mine is white gold with a braided type pattern in 14k yellow gold. $900 canadian. my 2 cents —